Supernatural Polls | Supernatural | The CW Indianapolis

Read the snarkiest quotes from each episode!

Get the latest cast news!

next on

show & cast

episode recaps

photos & video

features

Supernatural Polls

features | quotes | polls | news | shop Supernatural

What did you think of Dean making a deal with the Crossroads Demon to bring Sam back?
It was perfectly, tragically Dean – he’d do anything to save Sam
It was out of character – come on, he’s spent all season being pissed at John for doing the same thing!
It’s confusing – isn’t Dean always saying “What’s dead should stay dead”?
It was lazy writing on the show’s part – sure, Dean would want to make a deal, but why did they let him?

Did Sam come back from the dead… wrong?
No! He’s just the Sam we always knew!
Yes! He looked a little too dead-eyed psycho when he shot Jake over and over again.
Maybe not wrong, but he’s going to have a tough time coming to terms with Dean giving up his soul for him
I sure hope so – I love it when Sam is eeeeeeeevil!

Will you miss the Yellow-Eyed demon?
No! He destroyed everything the Winchesters loved! He was evil!
Yes! Sure, he was evil, but he was darn entertaining.
I have a feeling some of the demons released from hell will make our Yellow-Eyed friend look like a pussycat.
I will, but killing him was a perfect way to end the season – and this arc.

Best part of the episode:
Dean’s emotional speech to Sam’s corpse
Sam gasping his way back to life
The demon mocking anything and everything
Bobby kicking Dean’s ass for making the deal
The return of Ellen!
Papa Winchester helping to save the boys! Hi John! We miss you!
Sam shooting Jake - multiple times
The boys rededicating themselves to the Hunting life.

Who were you happiest to see return?
Andy – he’s a goofball, but I love him
Ava – well, before I figured out she was evil
Ava, even after she turned evil
Ash – I hope he survived!
Bobby! Always, always Bobby!

Is Sam dead?
What, are you crazy? Or course not! He's half the show.
It sure looked like it – Sob!
I don’t think he is, but Dean sure thinks so, and that’s all that counts.

How did Mary know the demon?
She was from a previous generation of demon-possessed kids
She was part-demon herself
She was psychic, and she saw him in her dreams
I don’t know, but I can’t wait to find out.

Most shocking moment:
The massacre in the diner
The destruction of the road house
The death of Lily
The reveal that Ava was evil
The death of Andy
Jake stabbing Sam

Was Sam right to let Jake live?
Of course –killing Jake would have been giving into the demon’s wishes
No! He had to know Jake wouldn’t be stopped.
In theory, but I kind of wish he’d tied Jake up – or at least not left the knife lying right next to him, and then turned his back on the guy. Dork.

Most wibble-worthy moment:
Dean yelling at John’s grave
Sam telling Dean that they had nothing in common
The moment Dean realizes that this is all just in his head
Sam telling Dean that he slept with Sam’s prom date – and Dean thinking it sounded like him
Dean admitting he wanted to stay in the dream world, even though he knew it wasn’t real
Sam telling Dean he was glad Hunting brought them together

Favorite Dean enjoying real life moment:
Chowing down on Mom’s BLT
Mowing the lawn and waving at the neighbors
Confronting a haute cuisine dish, then having his girlfriend tell him they could get a cheeseburger
Being thrilled to see Sam and Jess
The little eyebrow quirk he gave when Carmen first kissed him – like “Dude! This rocks!”

Most disconcerting moment:
Dean seeing the bodies in the closet
The girl in white appearing and disappearing
The djinn drinking straight from the IV tube
The garden gnome by the lawn—they’re creepy!
All the pictures of John being a happy father – it just looked… wrong. And badly photoshopped

You get trapped by a djinn. Which would you rather do?
Embrace the fantasy world, even though you’d die
Struggle back to the real world, even though it was full of pain and suffering

What was your favorite Dean snarky prison moment?
When he posed and pouted for his mug shot
When he told Hendrickson he thought he was adorable
The way he referenced every prison movie ever made at some point during their stay in the lock-up
The way he won just about every cigarette in the yard playing poker
When he promised he wouldn’t trade Sam for smokes

What was your favorite Sam-being-pissed-about-prison moment?
Sam pointing out that research could be difficult, as they were in jail
When he called Dean on how well he was fitting in
Answering the question about how he got sent to jail with “Because I’ve got an idiot for a brother”
The look on his face when he realized his cellmate was even bigger than he was
When he threw that “really pretty sure” response back in Dean’s face
His rant about how this was “the dumbest, craziest thing we’ve ever done, and that’s in a long, storied career of dumb and crazy”

What’s your take on Maura?
She’s a good lawyer who could see that there was more going on than your standard crime spree
She was blinded by how good Dean’s biceps looked in that prison jumpsuit. Rowr!
She’s secretly eeeeeevil and helping them escape was part of some demonic plan

What did you think of the episode overall?
Pretty much perfect
So funny, with all the snark and the great lines!
Sort of off – why weren’t the guys more worried?
Completely wrong – it contradicted the spirit of Night Shifter and everything that came after

What are your thoughts on the ramifications of Sam and Madison’s relationship?
Because Sam killed Madison to save her, it foreshadows a time when Dean will have to do the same thing.
I was glad Sam got a little extra shot of confidence… until it all went wrong.
This is the first time Sam has really done the killing, isn’t it? I doubt it will be the last.
Sam finally had to realize that no, not everyone can be saved.
This incident should pretty much turn Sam off sex for life.
OHMIGOD NEKKID SAM HOTTTT DROOL YOWZA!

Did Madison really have to die?
Yes. There was no way to cure her.
No – they should have kept trying to save her for real.
If she only turns when she’s asleep during the full moon, couldn’t she just have gotten a night job and slept during the day?
The biceps…. The back… the hands… the kissing!….wow.

What’s your favorite iconic horror beastie?
Werewolf
Vampire
Witch
Zombie
Guh…. Sam…. Naked… Sorry, what was the question?

Sam! Naked!!!!
I KNOW! It was AWESOME!
Yes, you might have mentioned that approximately 3,000 times. You’re starting to scare us.
Eh. I’d prefer Dean naked.
Sam who? I was focusing on Emmanuelle Vaugier.
Let it go! Yes, he’s hot, but that was hardly the point of the episode.
I’m shocked, shocked! at the base objectification of men you’re perpetrating here. Shame!

What was the best part of the episode?
Fire! Fire! I soooo missed the salting and burning of corpses. What does that say about me?
Tricia Helfer’s performance – she just rocked.
Finding all the sneaky clues that should have told me Molly was dead.
The whole gentle, melancholy tone of the episode.

When did you figure out Molly was dead?
When the previouslies reminded us that not all supernatural things are evil
When Molly didn’t have a scratch on her after the crash
When the guys kept exchanging significant looks whenever Molly talked about her husband
When Molly’s car was gone
When Dean didn’t hit on Molly
When Sam was all super-sensitive to Molly
When they came out and told me
Wait – Molly was dead? No way!

Tricia Helfer guest stars! Which other current sci-fi-tinged show should Supernatural turn to for guest actors?
Doctor Who
Lost
Heroes
The Dresden Files
Jericho
Smallville
Seventh Heaven (What? It rose from the dead…)

What was your favorite point-of-view moment?
Sam seeing Dean as a horny, sloppy drunk
Dean seeing Sam as a blah blah blah buzzkill
Sam seeing Dean stuffing his face like a chipmunk
Dean seeing Sam get all touchy-feely-emo-huggy on the unsuspecting student

What was your favorite Bobby moment?
His disbelieving rant about aliens not being real
Breaking up the guys when they’re sniping at each other
Verbally dopesmacking the guys for letting the Trickster get to them
Interrupting the guys’ touching moment over the car roof to tell them to hurry up and get out of there
Every moment with Bobby is my favorite moment!

What was your favorite Trickster trick?
Confronting a womanizing ethics professor with a dead girl
Curtis’ probes – and the slow dancing
The alligator in the sewers
The porntastic setup as a peace offering for Dean
Creating some buxom babes to share his supper
Conjuring a chainsaw murderer
The fake-out at the end

What were your all-over favorite parts of the episode?
The gory bits, like the alligator-gnawed arm and leg
The guys’ wrestling slap fight over Sam’s money clip
Dean purposely trying to annoy Sam by turning up the music, slurping down chili fries, and all the rest
Bobby rolling his eyes and having to separate the guys like they were kids

Evil!Sam:
Creepy!
Fantastic!
Fantastically creepy!
My new boyfriend!
Horrible! I hated him! Make it stop!

Did John really kill Jo’s father?
Of course not—you can’t trust information you get from a demon.
Of course – that sounds exactly like something John would do
Maybe, but if so, it really was to stop Bill’s suffering.

Best part of the episode:
Evil!Sam clocking Dean
Evil!Sam menacing Jo
Dean lying that Sam had sneaked out to a Justin Timberlake concert
The many, many Sam/Dean fight scenes
Bobby. Everything about him just rocks!

Scariest part of the episode:
Evil!Sam on video, slitting the hunter’s throat
Evil!Sam attacking Jo
Evil!Sam shooting Dean
Evil!Sam breaking the demon trap circle
Evil!Sam beating Dean up

Do you think there are angels in Sam and Dean’s world?
Sure – if there are demons, there must be angels.
No – if there were angels, the guys would have run into them by now.
I kind of think Sam and Dean are angels, or are at least doing the work of the angels.

Was Father Gregory’s spirit doing the right thing?
Yes – he was smiting evil men who were doing terrible things.
No – he was manipulating vulnerable people to give up their lives for a false cause.
Maybe, but he really needed to pay more attention to that “Thou shalt not kill” thing.

Funniest part of the episode:
Dean enjoying the Magic Fingers
Sam joking about unicorns
Dean pulling out his flask (in church!) when confronted with news of an angel
Sam trying to explain to Father Reynolds about the séance

What did Dean see at the end?
A gruesome, but poetic death
God’s will
A coincidence

Which was the most awesome fighting moment?
Dean fighting the shapeshifter, even when she was shedding her skin
Sam taking out two SWAT dudes and stealing their uniforms so they could escape

What did you think of Ron?
I loved Ron! He was such a lovable lunk.
He was actually pretty smart, even though he jumped to the wrong conclusion about the shapeshifter.
He was sweet, but not too bright. Seriously – mandroids?
He bugged the hell out of me.

What’s your impression of Hendrickson?
I respect him – he’s a great foil to the Winchester boys.
I hate him – how dare he put the boys in jeopardy like that?
Like Gordon, he’s obsessed and he doesn’t care who gets hurt in his quest to get his Winchester.

How screwed are the boys?
Pretty screwed
Completely screwed
So screwed that I have no idea how they’re going to get out of this
What are you talking about – they’ll be fine!

Who spilled Sam's secret to Gordon?
Ellen – she’s lying about forgiving John for Bill’s death.
Jo – she was looking for respect from a hunter, and it slipped out.
Ash – he resents being the boy’s performing research monkey.
One of the other hunters in the bar figured it out.
None of them – Gordon was bluffing..

What’s the deal with Ava?
She’s evil! She’s been working with the yellow-eyed demon the whole time!
She’s good, and now the demon has taken her prisoner to try to turn her bad!
She’s very, very dead.
She’s in hiding now that her fiancé is dead
I don’t know, but I hope we see her again soon.

Should the boys kill Gordon?
Yes – it’s the only way he’ll stop coming after them.
Nah – prison should hold him for at least a little while.
No – if they kill him, they’re no better than him.

What are you most looking forward to now that Supernatural's coming back from the holiday break?
Finding out what the big secret is.
Seeing what the yellow-eyed demon has in store for the world.
The return of Gordon!
Brother angst!
Gore! Monsters! Ass-kicking!
Just getting a chance to be with the brothers again on a weekly basis. I love those Winchester boys!

What’s your opinion about this episode?
Oooh, the slow-building tension had me on the edge of my seat.
I agree with the “slow” part, but I didn’t get the “tension” part.
Where were the explosions? I wanted zombie riots and explosions!
The horror plot was just a sideshow – it was all about the brothers, and that was fantastic!

The cutaway ending was:
Perfect! I’ll be salivating for the answer until the next new episode.
Frustrating! You’ve done it before, Kripke, so the surprise factor is gone.
Mean! You’re teasing us and then not following through!
No big deal. We’ll figure out the secret eventually, and you didn’t really believe they were going to spill tonight, did you?

Most shocking part of the episode:
Dean executing Mrs. Tanner
Sam getting attacked and infected
Sam offering to kill himself so Dean didn’t have to
Duane killing Sarge
The cut to black before Dean could spill the big secret

Funniest part of the episode?
Sam pouting that he’s not in the FBI database
Dean pondering the porn potential of MySpace
Sam catching Dean’s leg before he could kick in the second door, then rolling his eyes when it was unlocked
Sam’s nervous, delicate hop into the protective circle

Creepiest part of the episode?
The invisible Hellhound mauling the not-so-good doctor
The invisible Hellhound making claw marks in the floor
Evan’s wife morphing into crazy demonic faces
The demon shoving her tongue down Dean’s throat
The thought of one of those huge Black Dogs humping my leg. Ew!

So if it wasn’t a terribly bad idea that would end with pain and suffering and hellhounds and whatnot, what would tempt you to make a deal with a demon?
Money
Fame
Talent
Love
Protecting someone else

Was Dean really considering swapping his soul for John’s?
No – it was all just a ploy!
Yes – he was so close to doing it
Not until the demon told him that John was suffering horribly in hell

Linda Blair! The Exorcist! Whoo! What other horror legends would you like to see on the show?
Bruce Campbell – Evil Dead rules!
Robert Englund – He freaked me out as Freddy Krueger
Janet Leigh – Is there anything more iconic than the shower scene in Psycho?
Jamie Lee Curtis – She's the original scream queen!
Jack Nicholson – How cool would it be for Jack to see Dean's Jack impersonation?

Funniest moment of the episode:
The discussion of which of the brothers would be Scully
Dean's mock personal ad during his confession
The "Previously" montage of all the fake identities
Both brothers independently calling their lawyer "Matlock"
Dean making bizarre noises while Sam works on the computer

Is Dean responsible for John’s death?
Well, yeah – John died so that Dean could live.
Of course not – John chose to die, and Dean has nothing to do with it.
I still think the demon is responsible for John’s death, what with the fact it killed him and everything.

Most disturbing part of the episode:
Neal making out with a dead chick
Angela slowly pulling the scissors out of her chest
Dean going ballistic on an innocent, grieving old man
Sam studying porn like it was going to be on the test

Did Angela deserve to live?
Sure – it wasn’t her fault some pervert brought her back.
No – what’s dead should stay dead (except Dean).
She would have had a much better case for it if she hadn’t gone around killing people.

Vampires:
I'm with Gordon – they're inherently evil, and must be destroyed.
I'm with Lenore – they can evolve and improve, and they deserve a chance.
I'm with Dean – maybe these vamps were ok, but most of them should be beheaded.
I'm with Sam – ask questions first, behead only if necessary.

What was the best part of the episode?
The moral angst
The blood and guts
The deep philosophical questions
The awesome fights
The return of the metallicar!

Clowns:
Yay! I love clowns!
Eh, they’re just guys in face paint and floppy shoes
I’ll admit, they’re kind of creepy
Clowns are seriously scary.

Who’s your favorite of the new hunters?
Ellen – she’s obviously a tough old broad who can take care of herself.
Jo – she’s young, but she can still kick butt.
Ash – a mullet and a computer genius? Awesome!
I’d rather have John back. Oh, John, how could you leave us?

Which is scarier?
Planes – they crash!
Clowns – they kill!
Heck, everything’s scary when the Winchester brothers encounter it.

What did John whisper to Dean that freaked him out so much?
“Hey, so I made a deal with the Demon to save your life… but I’m sure it will all work out okay!”
“About your brother… I think the Demon is Sam’s real father. Keep an eye on him.”
“I never wanted to be a demon hunter. I wanted to devote my life to accountancy.”
“Elroy McGillicudy’s insurance will be rejected, so you might need to sneak out of the hospital in the middle of the night.”
“I never liked your taste in music. I’m more of a Smooth Jazz kind of guy.”
“Why don’t you junk the Metallicar and get a nice hybrid?”

What would you do if you met up with the Reaper?
Give in. It’s obviously my time to go.
Fight like hell, even it meant becoming a restless spirit somewhere down the line.
Challenge it to a game of chess for my soul. It worked in all those depressing Swedish movies, right?
Wait for it to become a hot chick/hot guy and flirt like there’s no tomorrow.

John’s final sacrifice was...
... shocking. Who knew he had such fatherly impulses in him?
... tragic. They were just starting to become a family again!
... expected. What else could he do to keep his son (and a main character) alive?
... selfish. So now the guys have to fight the demon without his help?

Supernatural is back for a second season! What's your main reason for watching?
I loooooove the scares
It's all about those pretty, pretty boys
I'm in it for the quips and snappy dialogue
The monsters are just a sideshow - I like the family moments and brotherly bond
Dude, the soundtrack rocks!
I'm a fan of the car - ok, the Metallicar

What do you think of the end of the episode?
GAHHH! How could they do this to me?!?
Now THAT, my friends, is what you call a cliffhanger!

Should Sam have shot John in the end?
Yes – he needed to kill the demon!
No – family is more important than demon slaying.
Yeah, he should have shot John. John pissed me off!

Best thing about the episode:
Meg getting shot
John turning the water supply into holy water
Dean finally confronting their dad about never picking up the freaking phone!
The guys bonding in the hotel room after their bout of attempted demon-slaying.
The opening credits! Rock on to Kansas, baby! Whooo!

Is John dead?
Oh, yeah. Those demons were pissed!
No way! John Winchester can survive anything!
I bet he’s still alive now, but that he’ll sacrifice his own to take out the demon.

Do vampires have as much right to live as humans do?
Sure – they're living creatures, sort of.
No! They're evil by definition!
In theory, but dude, they eat us!

John is:
A caring father
A dictatorial schmuck
A little crazy
All of the above

Sam and Sarah?
I can see it – she’s got moxie!
No way – Sam’s a drifter, he was born to walk alone!
No way -- Jess is Sam’s only true love!
No way -- I am Sam’s only true love!

What was the creepiest part of the episode?
The father moving in the portrait
The children’s toys in the mausoleum
The little girl herself
The woman’s head almost falling off
The idea of a bunch of rich people pawing over a recently murdered couple’s belongings for the thrill of it

Was it Dean’s fault the Shtriga attacked Sam when they were kids?
Of course – he never should have left the room.
Of course not! That’s way too much responsibility for a kid!
I think Papa Winchester was using the boys as bait for the Shtriga, so it was his fault!
I don’t think you can really assign blame when you're talking about scary supernatural beasties.

Would you rather know there are scary things out there, or retain your innocence?
I wouldn’t want to know – ignorance is bliss.
I’d want to know – knowledge is power!
I’d only want to know if I had access to the kind of arsenal the Winchesters do.
I don’t even want to think about it now! Happy place! HAPPY PLACE!

Michael was:
Adorable, in the wisecracking smart-alecky kid way.
Annoying, in the wisecracking smart-alecky kid way.
Heartbreaking, in the wisecracking smart-alecky kid who is growing up too fast way.
Not nearly as cute as little Dean.

Prank war! What’s the best prank?
Compromising photos taken when the victim is asleep.
Tuning the radio to a horrible station and turning the volume all the way up.
Itching powder in the underwear – it’s a classic!
Superglue on the beer bottle
Posing as a movie producer to get the geeks to shut down their website
Hiding a dead fish in someone’s car

Which do you hate more, rats or ghosts?
Rats – they’ve got those beady eyes and scaly tails, and they carry plague! Eeek!
Ghosts – They’re ghosts! And they can kill you! Eeek!

Would you watch Mordecai Murdoch, the movie?
Sure, Mordecai seems like a great unkillable boogeyman in the tradition of Jason and Freddy.
No, I prefer classic horror, like Dracula and Frankenstein.
I’m holding out for Snakes on a Plane.
I don’t know if I’d watch that movie, but I’d love to see the Winchester brothers meet up with Ed and Harry again!

What should have tipped the guys off that Meg was evil?
She just happened to turn up in the bar in Chicago
She wasn't interested in Dean
She got naked in front of the window with the lights on
Sam should have figured it out when he first met her

Should the guys and their father split up?
Yes, they distract each other too much
No, if they work together, they can protect each other

What’s scarier?
Supernatural beasties – they can’t be killed by normal means.
People – they're crazy!

Creepiest part of the house?
The jaw-bone windchime
The jar of teeth
The pictures of “hunting trophies”
The really disturbing kitchen implements
The family itself

Does Dean know something that Sam doesn't?
Yes – he didn't seem that surprised by Sam's new powers.
Maybe – I think their dad might have warned Dean that things would get freaky.
No – Dean is just naturally unflappable after years of ghost hunting.

Is the Winchester family cursed?
Yes – something made the flame demon purposely target Sam.
No – demons are fickle, and they'll torture whoever they want.
Not cursed, but there's definitely something going on with them.

What's the coolest power?
Telekinesis – I'd love to be able to move things with my mind.
Precognition – I'd totally use my talents in Vegas with Dean!
Does unnatural hotness count as a power? Because both brothers have that one.

Should Dean have stayed with Cassie?
No -- he’s got important work to do
Yes – it’s true love!
Even if he stayed, things probably wouldn’t have worked out between them.

Was Sam out of line when he put the “hallowed ground” plan into action?
Yes – he had no idea if it would work, and Dean could have been killed!
No – it was a gutsy reaction to a desperate situation.
Not with the plan, but he definitely shouldn’t have told Dean he didn’t know if it would work.

Why was Dean so snarky in the face of death?
He's a good soldier, and he knew that death was always a risk.
He wanted to put on a brave face for Sam.
He's emotionally incapable of dealing with tough moments.
He knew he'd be saved somehow.

What was the most heart-wrenching moment of the episode?
Sam leaving a message for their dad – not to ask for help, but to tell him he was handling the situation.
Dean muttering that Layla deserves to live much more than he does.
Ray realizing that his gift had deserted him.
Layla telling Dean she still had faith.
Dean telling Layla he'd pray for her.

Should Sam and Dean go their separate ways?
No – they need each other.
Yes – Sam's not going to be happy until he finds out what happened to Jess.
Sure – Dean can handle things himself (usually).

Best line of the episode?
I hope your apple pie is freaking worth it!
Hold me, Sam – that was beautiful.
You trust shady van guy and not me?
They're going to kill us? Sacrifice us. Which is, I dunno, classier I guess.

Who is Meg?
An evil groupie
Daughter of the demon who killed Mama Winchester
A witch
A random force of evil
Their sister

Would you spend the night in a haunted insane asylum?
Yeah! I love creepy, scary stuff!
Of course – none of that stuff is real.
Um, no – haunted plus insane equals really bad idea.

Does Sam really hate Dean?
No – he was possessed!
Yeah, he's got some unspoken issues with Dean
Of course he hates him. And loves him. That's what brothers do.

Best line of the episode?
See, that attitude, right there – that's why I always got the extra cookie.
Who do you think is the hotter psychic – Patricia Arquette, Jennifer Love Hewitt, or you?
Why would anyone want a job like that? I had a crappy guidance counselor.
If we make it out of here alive… we are so breaking up.
I love the guy, but I swear, he writes like freakin' Yoda.

What was the creepiest moment in this episode?
The monkey starting up and the garbage disposal shredding the plumber's hand
The chair sliding away from the closet door
The kitchen utensils trying to spear Dean
The fiery figure approaching Sam while he’s pinned to the wall

What was the funniest moment in the episode?
Dean talking about the man who shot himself in the head – three times!
Anytime Missouri reads Deans mind and chews him out
Missouri telling Dean he was a “goofy-looking child”
Sam laughing when Missouri chewed Dean out

What was the most tragic moment of the episode?
Dean calling his dad, begging for help
Mary disappearing in flames – again
Sam asking Missouri if even his mother’s spirit is gone
John looking like hell when he says he can’t see his sons yet

What was the funniest part of the episode?
Dean meditating on whether to pursue honest work or work that is fun and easy.
Larry and Linda assuming Dean and Sam were a gay couple.
Dean playing into the assumption by calling Sam “honey.”
Dean reacting to when Sam asked “You watch Oprah?”
Dean wrapped in a towel, testing the steam shower.

Bugs:
Ew! Ew! Ew!
Awesome! Bugs are cool!
Eh, they don’t bother me one way or the other.

Should Matt have told his father the truth?
Yes – honesty is always the best policy.
Tell your parents the truth? What kind of madness is that?
In most cases, yes, but not so much with the “Hey, Dad, a biblical plague of insects is coming to kill us.”

What's the best thing about college?
The camaraderie of fraternities and sororities
The school spirit, as exemplified by Purple Man
The opportunity to study and stretch your mind
Being surrounded by a passel of hot hot 18- to 24-year olds

Should Sam have stayed with Lori?
Yes – they both need to heal and get over their guilt.
No – he has a mission to find Jessica's killer.

What's the scariest artifical part on an evil being?
Hook hand
Peg leg
Evil glass eye
Any bit (hand, leg, knee cap) from an executed killer
Accursed breast implants

What did you think of the shapeshifter's transformation?
Cool! I love blood and gore!
Disgusting! I didn't need to see bleeding gums and teeth popping out.
I can't believe they got away with putting that on primetime TV.
It wasn't graphic enough for my tastes.

Would you like to attend your own funeral?
Sure -- I'd love to see what all my friends had to say about me!
No way – it would be too depressing.
Maybe, but not if the cops thought I was a multiple murderer.

Was Sam sincere when he told Dean he didn't miss his old life?
Yes – he's always known in the back of his head that he was different.
No – he was just trying to make up for the hurt feelings that the shapeshifter revealed Dean had.

Is Sam responsible for Jessica's death?
Yes - he should have told her about his dreams
No - Jessica never would have believed him
Maybe - he probably couldn't have stopped it, but he should have done something

What's your favorite slumber party freak-out?
Bloody Mary
Light as a feather, stiff as a board
Flashlight ghost stories
Calling members of the opposite sex

Why did Sam see Jessica?
She's warning him
She's accusing him
She misses him
He's going insane

In his black suit, Dean looks like:
One of the Blues Brothers
A seventh grader going to his first dance
A federal agent
A hottie!

Did the demon really know what happened to Jessica?
Yeah, and it wasn’t pretty.
No, it was lying.

Are you afraid of flying?
No – you have more chance of dying in a car crash.
Yes – how does the plane stay up in the sky?
Well, I am now.

What's the worst way to die?
Drowning
Fire
Eaten by vicious beasts
Boredom

Would you swim in a lake?
No way – there could be nasty creatures in there!
Sure – it's swimming as nature intended.
It doesn't count unless there are waves.
I prefer to stay on dry land.

Would you fall for Dean's pickup lines?
Swoon! Yes!
No way -- they're too cheesy.

My thoughts on camping:
I love camping!
I hate camping.
I used to like it, but not after watching this episode!

Where do you think Sam and Dean's dad is waiting for them?
Back in Kansas, at the site of their old home
In the cemetery where their mom is buried
In the Bermuda Triangle
In Hell, Michigan
Where they least expect it

Hey, nice Carrie fake-out in the opening dream sequence! What other classic horror flicks do you want Supernatural to reference?
Nightmare on Elm Street – Sam wakes up from a dream with actual injuries!
Dracula – they meet a mysterious man who doesn't drink…wine.
Night of the Living Dead – Brains! Brains!
Plan 9 from Outer Space – a villain suddenly becomes a foot taller and the scenery changes from day to night.

How scary was Supernatural?
You call that scary?
I'll admit it, I jumped.
I slept with the light on.
I needed a change of underwear.

What urban legend do you want to see next on Supernatural?
A killer calling the babysitter from inside the house
El Chupacabra
The Jersey Devil
Bigfoot
I have no idea what you're talking about.

Who's your favorite Winchester brother?
Dean – he's a rebel, a fast talker, and he's got great taste in music!
Sam – he's sensitive, rational and romantic!
I like them both equally.
It's too soon to tell!
I prefer the doomed girlfriend.